my weekend tech project

[Microdot]

so... i was in dire need of expansion. we've gotten a lot of new clients in the last couple of months, and as a result, have increased the amount of crap i have here stored. i have plenty of internal storage... but up until this point, was running half as live, and the other half as onsite backup.

so.. the issue: i have 6tb of internal storage to backup (right now... that may soon grow)... and needed to build something large enough to encompass it all with room to grow. at the same time... not cost me a fucking arm and two legs.

the goal: find something that would give me TONS of space (minimum 8tb, preferably expandable), for less than $1500.

so i started researching last week. i looked at a drobo first (as well as a drobo pro)... there are just too many issues that ive seen with it and time machine to be a viable option. as well, ive got a real hangup about using a proprietary system that only THEY can restore. no thanks. added to that... fw800 is the fastest thing available... and its just a no brainer... pass.

then i started looking at other external drives... the only other thing i could find in a 'prebuilt' solution was the lacie quadra (and quadra stack). it has a lot of pluses going for it... removable drives... no proprietary bullshit... simple, effective, and ready to go out of the box. the ONLY downside.... the price tag. to just get by with enough space, i would have to go with the 8tb 4big model... and the avg price on that thing online is around $1700. ouch. i would still have to buy an esata controller as well (or run it through fw800... which is ok, but moving that much data, its just not feasible)

so i decided i was going to have to build my own array. i started looking at all the options out there... external raid arrays in all shapes and sizes. the end result: a sans digital tr5m1 towerraid. there are bigger options out there (they have an 8 bay model) but most limit to 5 drives in the array, and more than that starts to put too much load on the controller anyway. but it fit my needs... 5 bays, esata, quiet, and hot swappable. its best feature... the pricetag. only $199 at frys. the only issue: the supplied controller is shit. it runs off of a sil3132 chipset that has spotty 64bit support, and ZERO snow leopard support. but, at $199, it was still a good deal, even without the controller.

so... i started looking around at the options for esata controllers. there were only two to choose from that stated explicitly they supported 64 bit, and more importantly, snow leopard. sonnet and highpoint. after looking at the specs and speed comparisons, i went with the highpoint rocketraid esata for mac.. it works perfectly.

so... after all the components were decided upon, i went after my plan. purchased the sans digital 5 bay enclosure, the highpoint controller, and 5 x 2tb hard drives:

sans digital: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16816111049
rocketraid: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16816115068
hdd: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16822148413

grand total: $1,340.92

so i saved around $550 over the lacie option, and got an extra 2tb worth of storage in the process. and, should i need to in the future, i can duplicate this process using the same card, for right at $1k (giving me 20tb of storage).

it may not be the most "professional" solution... but it accomplished my needs, and did so WELL within the budget i wanted. mission accomplished.

[wastern]

Good luck with the controller. We use a few different ones at work, some of the newer (not brand new) stuff is using an LSI 8k. It's a giant pile of shit. The older LSI shit is better, but still not good. Especially if you have multiple arrays

most of out San is handled by EMC though. It's nice having someone worry about it for you

[Microdot]

Originally Posted by wastern

Good luck with the controller. We use a few different ones at work, some of the newer (not brand new) stuff is using an LSI 8k. It's a giant pile of shit. The older LSI shit is better, but still not good. Especially if you have multiple arrays

most of out San is handled by EMC though. It's nice having someone worry about it for you

yeah... lsi is kind of hit and miss. i have a few controllers that ive installed that have lasted a long time... others dropped in a month. bang for the buck, they arent bad... but i wouldnt trust my life with them.

ive had decent results on avg with highpoint and adaptec. the biggest plus with highpoint is they actively support their product (not that adaptec doesnt... but they tend to be a little slower - highpoint had snow leopard drivers available BEFORE the release date). drivers and updates for EVERY system are up and running almost immediately after an issue pops up. cant say the same for most others. (for example... silicon image... they have a HUGE install base, as they are fairly cheap. at this point, there are no snow leopard drivers at all, and the 64bit drivers they have for vista have never worked right. )